How to Choose the Right Property for Your First Short-Term Rental


Alicia Lytle, JD

April 15th

🏡 How to Choose the Right Property for Your First Short-Term Rental

↓
​

So, you're ready to dive into short-term vacation rental investing—but where do you start?

Before you grab the keys to your first property, it’s crucial to understand one thing: not all homes make great short-term rentals. A beautiful house isn’t enough. You need the right property in the right location with the right strategy behind it.

Here’s how to make a smart, profitable choice from day one:


1. Start with Strategy, Not Emotion

It’s tempting to pick a home you personally love—but this is a business. Ask yourself:
✔ Who is my ideal guest?
✔ What kind of experience am I offering?
✔ Does this property support my income goals?

Start with clarity so you can select a home that aligns with your vision and your bottom line.


2. Location Isn’t Just About Scenery

Yes, beach views and mountain vibes are a plus—but proximity matters more.
Look for properties near:

  • Popular attractions
  • Hospitals or universities
  • Convention centers or airports
  • High-demand vacation zones

Bonus tip: Avoid areas with heavy STR restrictions (more on that next).


3. Understand Local Regulations

Before you buy, check:

  • Zoning laws
  • Licensing and permits
  • HOA rules
  • City or county STR caps

You don’t want to find your dream property only to discover short-term rentals are prohibited.


4. Evaluate the Property’s Layout

Some homes are just better suited for STRs. Look for:
✔ Multiple bedrooms and bathrooms
✔ Open living spaces for entertaining
✔ Guest-friendly amenities (hot tub, pool, outdoor seating)
✔ Private entrances for multi-unit potential

Avoid properties with lots of stairs, confusing layouts, or limited parking.


5. Run the Numbers Honestly

Don’t guess—analyze. Use tools like AirDNA, Mashvisor, or even comps on Airbnb to estimate:

  • Occupancy rates
  • Nightly rates
  • Monthly income
    Then subtract estimated expenses, cleaning, and management costs. If the numbers don’t make sense, walk away.

6. Think Like a Guest

What would you want as a guest in that space?
✔ Is it peaceful?
✔ Is it clean and safe?
✔ Would you book it again?

If the answer is yes—and the math works—you may have found a winner.


Final Thoughts

The right property is the foundation of your entire short-term rental business. Choose wisely, and you’ll set yourself up for years of passive income, glowing reviews, and true financial freedom.

If you’re still unsure, don’t worry—I walk you through this step-by-step inside The Ultimate STVR Blueprint. But this guide? It’s your first smart step.


1317 Edgewater Dr. #3172, Orlando, FL 32804
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

background

Subscribe to Alicia Lytle